The Creative Hats Readback

How to give and receive feedback on creative writing

Someone reads your story and tells you they enjoyed it. You’re pleased, of course. But what you want to know is whether they understood why she went back into the house.

In a Readback, readers tell you what they made of your draft and show you where they got that impression. You use Keep, Query, Try to take one thing worth keeping, one question and one change to test into your next draft.

How to give feedback on a draft

Give your reader a question

For a writing group or a draft swap with a critique partner, bring up to three pages or a short poem. Say what stage it’s at and what you want to find out. ‘When did you realise the vicar was lying?’ gives your reader a job they can do. If you’re swapping drafts by email, put the question above the excerpt.

Mark what happened as you read

Note where you laughed, got lost or changed your mind about a character. Mark the line or page where it happened. In the discussion, start with the writer’s question. ‘I suspected the vicar when he knew which drawer held the bread knife’ gives the writer a clue they can look at.

Compare where readers got their ideas

If two readers disagree, ask each to point to the words that led them there. One may have remembered the bread knife while the other missed it because they were following an argument in the same scene. The writer gets to decide whether that difference is worth doing something about.

Keep, Query, Try

At the end, write down one of each. Here’s what that might look like after reading a scene about a sister who leaves with the keys.

Keep

What would you miss if it went?

‘The sister puts the keys in her coat pocket before she says goodbye. Keep that. It made me wonder whether she meant to come back.’

Query

What did the draft leave you wondering?

‘I thought she was leaving for good. Did you mean for me to expect her back by dinner?’

Try

What could you change on a spare copy?

‘Give her a reason to need the keys again that evening. Read the goodbye with that detail in place and see whether it changes what the reader expects.’

If you have time, read the changed bit aloud with your reader. You can put the old line back if it does the job better.

What a work in progress could look like

These sketches, handwritten drafts and marked-up pages give you somewhere to start. Pick one detail in a draft and tell the writer what it made you imagine. That could be the first thing they write under Keep.

Questions about creative writing feedback

What makes feedback useful to a writer?

Name a moment, describe your reaction and point to the words that prompted it. ‘The ending confused me’ gives the writer a place to start. ‘I thought the sister still had the keys when the front door opened’ gives them something to check.

Should I correct spelling in a first draft?

Start with what the writer asks for. If they’re deciding whether a scene works, spend your time on the scene. Save a spelling and punctuation pass for when the wording has settled.

What if two readers give different feedback?

Ask what led each reader to their conclusion. If the draft supports both readings, ask yourself whether you want that ambiguity. Try one small change and see what a fresh reader makes of it.

Can I use the Readback with poetry or memoir?

Yes. With a poem, ask where an image stuck or where a line break changed how someone heard it. With memoir, ask where the reader lost track of time or wanted to stay in a memory for longer.

Written by Kelly Hatley, creative writing tutor and publisher at Creative Hats Press.

Explore our author resources or creative writing courses.